Best Handmade Preppy Items on Etsy

Looking for a gift? Searching for that perfect something for yourself? This list of handmade items has you covered! Shopping small is SO important! Not only are you supporting an individual, you are supporting their craft, their family, and helping them support their American Dream! I’ve compiled a list of the best Etsy products that provide gorgeous, handmade items you can feel great about buying, organized by category!
*Denotes items handmade in my home state of Michigan!
**Anything listed here that includes “Lilly Pulitzer” are items crafted with authentic Lilly Pulitzer fabrics!

This post contains affiliate links, meaning that if you click on a link and make a purchase, I may make a (very) small commission. The revenue generated from this helps maintain my site and allows me to continue creating beautiful content for you. Know that I never link to items I don’t absolutely love and highly recommend to you – thank you! 

Dark N Stormy Print:
Monogrammable DNS Car Mats $39.95
Monogram DNS Watch
Monogram DNS Vanity Plate $24
DNS Monogram Rain Jacket
DNS Pillow
DNS Pet Leash/Collars
DNS Bridal Garter
DNS Shift Dress Ornaments

Hotty Pink First Impressions Print:
Initial Pillow $36
Monogram Pillow $34
Hair Bow $5
72″ Pet Leash $22
Cummerbund & Bow Tie Set $120
Baby Bonnet $55
Cat Bed $45
Bachelorette Sash $32
Crib Rail Cover $105
Lamp Shade Cover $56
Large 3 Initial Monogram $45
Men’s Bow Tie Only $30

“You Gotta Regatta” Print Items:
Bridal or Birthday Sash $32
Fabric Clutch Bag $38
Hair Bow $12
Vanity Plate $25
Reversible YGR Bow Tie $35
YGR Sails Sailboat $95
Monogram or Greek Letters Sweatshirt $33
Banner $35
Monogram Decal $3.50
Pillow $30
Girl’s Skirt $27
Bow Tie $30

Red Right Return (RRR) Print Items:
Monogrammed Car Mats $40
Men’s Cummerbund and Bowtie Set $120
Father & Son Bow Tie Set $42
Bow Tie Only $27
Hair Bow $5.50
Baby Shoes $28.50
Fabric Clutch $38
Vanity Plate $6.50
Collar & Leash Set $59
Anchor Pillow $32
Disney Ears $25
Greek Baseball Shirt $32
4 Piece Coaster Set $14
Zip Bag $25
Brides Crew Tanks $25

Accessories:
Lilly Pulitzer Bow Bracelets 
Lilly Pulitzer Hair Bows
Lilly Pulitzer Monogramable Clutches
Lilly Pulitzer Clutches
Lilly Pulitzer Lanyards
Lilly Pulitzer Key Fobs 
Lilly Pulitzer Turban Style Headbands 
Lilly Pulitzer State Applique Hat
Monogrammed Greek Hat
Lilly Pulitzer Knotted Headband

Baby & Kids:
Baby Shoes in Red Right Return $28.50

HPFI Crib Rail
HPFI Baby Bonet
Lilly Pulitzer Applique Bloomers
Monogrammed Seersucker Maternity Sash/Baby Bow
Gold Monogram Kids Cup
Chevron Bow Headband
Lilly Printed Hair Bows
Lilly Pulitzer Manatee Plushee
Lilly Pulitzer Shift Dress Baby Quilt
Lilly Pulitzer Name Burp Cloth
Girl’s Mermaid Costume

Bags:
Monogram Navy Stripe Weekender Bag
Monogram Straw Market Tote with Stripes
Monogram Lilly Pulitzer Tennis Racket
Seersucker Monogram Makeup Bag
Lilly Pulitzer Applique Canvas Tote Bag
Scallop Monogram Leather Bag

Birthdays:
Lilly Pulitzer “Birthday Girl” Sash

Bridal:
YGR Bride to Be Sash
Summer Classic Print Lilly Fabric Garter
Monogrammed Keep & Toss Garter
Keep & Toss Garter Set, Various Lilly Prints
Mr. & Mrs. Stemless Wine Glasses
Lilly Pulitzer Bride/Maid of Honor/Bridesmaid Spirit Jersey
Lilly Pulitzer Garter Set
Lilly Pulitzer “Bachelorette” Sash
Monogram Bridal Party PFG Shirt
Lilly Pulitzer Mr. & Mrs. Applique Apron Set
Lilly Pulitzer “Bride to Be” Applique Sash

Career:
Lilly Pulitzer Scrub Top
Lilly Pulitzer Stethoscope Cover
Lilly Pulitzer Badge Holder

Clothing (Tops):
Gold Foil Sorority, Monogram and Bridal Items
Gold Foil Monogram Tank Top
Lilly Pulitzer Graduation Cap
Lilly Pulitzer Long Sleeve Pocket Tee
Lilly Pulitzer Monogram Baseball Hat
Lilly Pulitzer Pocket Tanks 
*Lilly Pulitzer State & Monogram Zip Up
Lilly Pulitzer Sun Hat w/Monogram
*Lilly Pulitzer Monogram, Sorority, School Sweatshirt 
*Lilly Pulitzer Zip Up
Lilly Puiltzer Cinderella’s Castle Tee
Lilly Pulitzer Rain Jacket
Lilly Pulitzer Donut Shirt
Lilly Pulitzer Breast Cancer Ribbon Tee
Lilly Pulitzer Windbreaker Jacket
Lilly Pulitzer Squirrel Shirt
Lilly Pulitzer Monogram Cover Up
Vineyard Vines/Lilly Pulitzer Print Shep Shirt
Lilly Pulitzer Bow Bikini
Lilly Pulitzer Applique Puffy Vest
Monogram 1/4 Zip
Lilly Pulitzer Baseball Raglan Top

Clothing (Bottoms):
Seersucker Monogram Shorts
Lilly Pulitzer Skirts

Decals Under $5:
Crab Decal
Gold Foil
Rapunzel Inspired Monogram
Sorority Iron on Glitter Decal
State Decal 
Gold Foil Scallop Monogram Phone Charger Decal 
4″ Pineapple Monogram 
Lilly Pulitzer Cat Monogram 
Elephant Monogram 
Fishing Monogram
Lilly Pulitzer Mandela
Lilly Pulitzer Seahorse
Lilly Pulitzer Sea Turtle
Lilly Pulitzer Whale Monogram
Lilly Pulitzer Print Starbucks Decal
Lilly Pulitzer Deer 

Decor:
Lilly Pulitzer Inspired Fresh Squeeze Painted Canvas
*Awesome Bubble Glazed Pottery 
*Customization wall art, calligraphy, watercolor prints, and so much more!  
Lilly Pulitzer Banner 
Lilly Pulitzer You Gotta Regatta Sailboat
Large Sailboat Painting
Lilly Pulitzer Light switch Covers!
Lilly Pulitzer Mini Monogram Pillows
Lilly Pulitzer Fabric Wrapped Photo Frame
Lilly Pulitzer/Lee Jofa Custom Curtains
Lilly Pulitzer Monogram Tissue Box Cover

Dining & Drinks/Party:
Lilly Pulitzer Tumbler 
Sorority Decal Tumbler 
Custom Lilly Pulitzer Starbucks Cup
Monogram Tea Cup
Lilly Pulitzer Stemless Wine Glasses
Lilly Pulitzer Painted Starbucks Cup
Lilly Pulitzer 30 oz. Monogrammed Yeti Cup
25 oz Monogrammed Camelbak Water Bottle
Personalized 25oz Camelbak Water Bottle
Lilly Pulitzer Printed Paper Party Straws (50 for $8!)
Set of 4 Lilly Pulitzer Fabric Napkins
Lilly Pulitzer Patchwork Cooler
Lilly Pulitzer Printed Koozies
Lilly Pulitzer Shift Dress Cookies
Custom Painted Hard Rolling Cooler
Paper Lilly Party Banner
Lilly Pulitzer Tile Coasters

Holiday Items:
Shift Dress Ornaments
Lilly Pulitzer Candy Cane Ornaments
Lilly Pulitzer Pumpkin Shirt
Custom Lilly Pulitzer Monogram Tree Skirt
Lilly Pulitzer Monogram Ice Skate Stocking
Lilly Pulitzer Monogram Stocking w/Scallops
Lilly Pulitzer Quilted Stocking
Lilly Pulitzer Travel Pillow 

Home & Office:
Lilly Pulitzer Bow Shaped Pillow
Lilly Pulitzer Shower Curtain in Get Nauti
Lilly Pulitzer Rugs
Lilly Pulitzer XL First Impressions Throw Blanket
Monogram Throw/Stadium Blanket
Lilly Pulitzer Hand Towels in DNS
Lilly Pulitzer Pom Pom Rectangular Pillow
Lilly Pulitzer Anchor Pillow
Lilly Pulitzer Bulletin Board in Just Add Mint
Lilly Pulitzer Bulletin Board in Pink Tusk in Sun
Lilly Pulitzer Bulletin Board in YGR 
Lilly Pulitzer Bulletin Board in Rule Breakers
Lilly Pulitzer Bulletin Board in In The Beginning
Lilly Pulitzer Name Pillow w/Pom Poms
Lilly Pulitzer Quilt
Lilly Pulitzer Queen Size Quilt
Lilly Pulitzer Queen Size Shift Dress Quilt
Lilly Pulitzer  Queen Size Elephant Quilt
Lilly Pulitzer Clothes Pins
Bright Rag Rug
Lilly Pulitzer/Lee Jofa Custom Curtains
Lilly Pulitzer Cushion on Bamboo Chair
Lilly Pulitzer Towel Bath Wrap
Lilly Pulitzer Pillow Sham
Monogram Lawn Chair

Jewelry:
Monogram Pearl Bracelet ($5!)
Monogram Earrings
Lilly Pulitzer Monogram Ring Dish $5
Lilly Pulitzer Sorority Bangle 

Men’s & Boy’s:
Red Right Return Father/Son Bow tie Set $42
Red Right Return Cummerbund & Bow Tie Set $120
HPFI Bow Tie Only
HPFI Cummerbund & BowTie Set $120
Gingham Ties (Buy 4 Get 1 Free!)
Lilly Pulitzer Neck Ties (Lobstah Roll, Lover’s Coral & Southern Charm)
Lilly Pulitzer Neck Ties (You Gotta Regatta, Going Coastal, & Exotic Garden)
Lilly Pulitzer Neck Tie (Trunk in Love, Pop Pop, Flamenco)
Lilly Pulitzer Neck Tie (Out to Sea, Pink Lemonade, Roar of the Sea)
Lilly Pulitzer Neck Ties (Lolita, Casa Banana, Coconut Jungle)
Lilly Pulitzer Boy’s Bow Ties
Lilly Pulitzer Men’s Bow Ties 
Seersucker Neck Ties & Bow Ties (Monogramable) 
Seersucker Suspenders
Seersucker Bow Ties (Buy 4 Get 1 Free!) 
Lilly Pulitzer Bow Tie & Cummerbund Set
Lilly Pulitzer Suspenders & Bow Tie Set

Other:
Lilly Pulitzer Steering Wheel Cover
Lilly Pulitzer Bible Cover
Lilly Pulitzer Car Trash Bag Cover
Lilly Pulitzer Ribbon in Various Prints
YGR Beach Towel
Variety of Prints Authentic Lilly Pulitzer Fabric By The Yard
2017 Not Yet Released Print Fabric By the Yard! 
Lilly Pulitzer Rugs
Monogrammed Lilly Pulitzer Pillows
Custom Sorority Sweatshirt with Auth. Lilly Fabric
Custom Lilly Fabric Zip UP
Custom Lilly Car Mats

Pets:
Lilly Pulitzer Collar
Lilly Pulitzer Printed Leash & Collar Set in Southern Charm

School/Office:
Lilly Pulitzer Binder Covers
Lilly Pulitzer Fabric Ipad Cover
Lilly Pulitzer Shift Dress Magnets

Shoes:
Lilly Pulitzer Painted Toms

Bath & Body Products:
Lilly Pulitzer Monogrammed Compact
Want to be added to the list? Contact me below with a link to your Etsy shop!